Biggest Draft Bust of All Time?
As a negotiating stipulation for the next collective bargaining agreement, the NBA Players Association is seeking to end the current age restriction. For those of you who don’t know, the last NBA collective bargaining agreement placed an age restriction of 19 years old and one year removed from high school on players entering the NBA draft. This rule has been under heavy scrutiny and has been a major topic for debate since the moment it was instated. Now that a new collective bargaining agreement is being negotiated, this hot button issue is once again under the microscope. Taking all facts into consideration, I believe that retracting this rule would be a huge mistake. Personally, I wouldn’t mind seeing the restriction being raised to 20 years old and two years removed from high school…but I digress. I know that my view on this subject is probably not the popular one, but that’s why it is MY view and not yours.
James Lang
- Darius Miles
I could look at this quandary one of two ways. As a businessman, a man, and most importantly a human being, I fully empathize with the players and their right to try to make a living as young adults after high school. On the other hand, I can also look at this situation as a fan and basketball purist, and as a fan and basketball purist, I think that the skill level of the NBA took an ENORMOUS dip in the years between 2001 and 2005, the years when the “straight from high school” to the NBA trend was at its peak. Looking at the league overall, that was the worst period of basketball I had ever witnessed in my life. The draft was more of a crap shoot than ever because teams were drafting 18 year old, “wet behind the ears”, neophytes that they KNEW wouldn’t contribute for AT LEAST three years, IF they ever ended up contributing at all. The word “POTENTIAL” ran rampant through NBA circles. But how much of that potential has ever come to fruition? For every Kevin Garnett, you had a C.J. Miles, a Ricky Sanchez, and a James Lang. For every Kobe Bryant, you had a Korleone Young, an Ndudi Ebi, and a Kwame Brown. For every Amare Stoudemire, you had a Darius Miles, a Sebastian Telfair, and a Jonathan Bender. For every Lebron James, you had a Leon Smith, an Eddy Curry, and a Shaun Livingston. For every…..well…..you get my point.
I’m tired of watching bad basketball, so PLEASE make these kids go SOMEWHERE to hone their skills before entering the “big leagues”. Isn’t that what the NBA Developmental League is SUPPOSED to be for anyway??? Just like in baseball, make your 18 year old “phenoms” play for your minor league aka D-League affiliate for a couple years, instead of abusing the purpose of the league and sending players down there as punishment and allowing 12-13 year old broke veterans to occupy slots just to get a steady paycheck. I talk with my Homie and co-host Jimmy about this subject quite often, and we both pretty much agree that forcing kids to go to college who neither have the desire nor the intention of becoming students is a bad idea and a waste of time for these athletes and for the universities. So NBA…PLEASE do not cave on this rule. PLEASE restructure your “D-League” plan and utilize it correctly. I am tired of seeing clean-faced, ultra skinny, uber athletes who do not know how to shoot, pass, dribble, THINK, or play defense. Save your product. Keep the rule!
Tags: Amare Stoudemire, C.J. Miles, Darius Miles, Devin McMillan, Eddy Curry, James Lang, James Williams, Jonathan Bender, Kevin Garnett, Kobe Bryant, Korleone Young, Kwame Brown, Lebron James, Leon Smith, NBA, NBDL, Ndudi Ebi, Ricky Sanchez, Sebastian Telfair, Shaun Livingston, The War Room, War Room Sports
I agree wholeheartedly, I also believe the league has a greater responsibility to these young, oft times, urban males. Giving 18 and 19 year old boys millions of dollars, fame, and keeping them in the company of grown men is a recipe for financial and social disaster. Compound that with the fact that many of these young men come from “have not” type backgrounds and in a society where material possession and status is lauded (as well as focus on the individual) you end up w/ a product (in this case the men in question) that are ill equipped in life and because of individual focus in your league. You can’t take a kid that’s been told he is “the next big thing” out of high school, put him in a professional environment where he still holds that tag and expect him to not be selfish and self-absorbed. Like you said… it waters down the league.
While the NBA has this issue on their hands as a league, the more general societal impact to these young men in the future is much more devastating. Just my $.02
I agree wholeheartedly with using the NBDL as a minor league in the baseball model. It will allow many of the young players to develop their game and mature away from the spotlight.
Let the young men play if they choose. Baseball, Hockey Tennis, and Golf all allow young men to turn pro at 18 or younger. The freedom to chose whether or not to work at age 18 as a pro in the NBA should be left up to the young men and their families to decide. The real deal is that the owners and league needs to have a better selection process to judge their talent that they select to enter the league. That is the real issue, they cannot judge talent. The argument that Germain uses is not all together true. These kids are lauded from as early as junior high or even earlier. The ones with lower values will already be tainted. It is up to the families to protect these young men form that not the NBA. A 18yr old young man can decide to go join the military and die for his country but cannot go to the NBA and sign a million dollar contract?? Whats wrong with this picture?
Is it because the majority of these young kids are black men? Hmmmmmmmmmmm?
Golf, Baseball, Hockey, tennis ect these issues are not brought up. It is how you select that 18 yr old kid. Does he have the moral vaules, talent, social skills, familiy to aid him in making it at the next level? That is what the league does a bad job of doing. Selection!